Halal Stock, Non-halal Stock
Wednesday, February 15th, 2006i’m soooo fuuulllll… had so much to eat…. department lunch… good food….
alhamdulillah.
this is in response to zeri’s concern on the stock exchange environment where stocks are traded freely whether or not they are halal.
just a background non-halal stocks would include the shares of companies whose nature of businesses involves alcohol, tobacco (sorry guys, i agree with smoking being haram), gaming, weapons, entertainment services, pork-related products, unslaughtered meat products, conventional financial services. i hope i have not missed anything out.
as you can see, most stock traded on the exchange will therefore be halal (compliant with Islamic principles). i chose to list out those that were haram because this is in line with the religion’s principle that "everything is halal, except those that are announced as haram. where would you find these announcements? this would be in the Qur’an and the Prophet’s Sunnah (traditions).
so getting to the point in question, is trading on the stock exchange haram because stocks may intermingle and stocks that are available for sale and purchase may or may not be halal. well, i’m far from a scholar in any religion let mine alone but there is nothing to say that a non-halal stock will contaminate a halal stock. stock are mutually exclusive and their profits respective profits do not intermingle (we are reliant on their disclosure of their business model).
a scenario likewise, canned soda are not pronounced haram and are not contaminated by the liquor that are kept on shelves around the corner. same way the holy Qur’an, books on science, car magazines, art books, interior decor brochures sitting in MPH are not haram-ised by the soft-porn Mills & Boon churn out. that sort of stuff are not for reading. sorry Mills & Boon fans.
the rules that apply to Muslim investors who are interested in securities investments are that the securities that they invest in are not interest bearing securities, i.e. corporate bonds, AND are not securities of companies that engage in the above-mentioned business models.
just a word of caution, there are a few misconceptions of the above principles where Muslim investors choose to follow one criteria and overlook the other. for example, there may be some who buy securities of less haram-prominent products such as banks (that do not provide 100% Islamic banking). their argument is that the shares they buy generate dividend and not interest. if we understand the concept of dividend correctly, it is actually the pay-out ratio per share pro-rated from the profit that the company earns. where is profit derived from in the conventional banking sector? INTEREST! you are actually earning dividends of interest.
some people still disagree with this. so i tell them, imagine dividends of a company that sells pork-related products or alcohol. would that not be haram? their answer is always, but pork / alcohol are outrightly (is there such a word?) haram.
well, i say, so is interest.
however, if you’re looking into mutual funds zeri, then yes, you have to wash out your investment portfolio and ensure that no non-halal stock has sneaked its way into the basket of eggs. if there are non-halal stock, yes, the investment is contaminated, as you put it.
on the wider picture still, since you’ve brought up the issue of the existence of stock on the exchange, i would have to ask why are they there in the first place? in a Islamic country, such stock should not exist on the exchange and neither should companies involved in such businesses exist.
therefore, it is not haram for us to buy a canned soda in a supermarket but it is not halal for the supermarket to be selling alcohol. it is not haram to buy stock of F&N, but it is not halal for the stock exchange to list the shares of guiness.
there are a few other concerns. for example, the most stable investment for malays, who are mostly Muslim, is ASB. the most reliable unit trust. are all shares in ASB compliant with Islamic principles?
furthermore, only about a year ago Malaysia amended(?) / upgraded (?) its Islamic (Shari’a) index to meet international Islamic standards. thus the RHB Islamic Index was launched. it was set at par with the Dow Jones Islamic Index. so all this while our Shari’a index was inaccurate?
i agree with zeri that we have to question quite a bit on the overall make-up of the economy. after all, main consumer spending and government revenue is from alcohol? cigarettes? sureheboh late night concerts?
i guess we have alot to learn and it’s not all too fair to pinpoint fault with the authorities all the time (i do it all the time). i mean, Islam is very new religion, much to the surprise of many. and we all have our own learning curves of Islam’s tenets.
as long as there are sincere efforts to improve and develop the economy to adhere to an Islamic environment, i guess we are on the right track. in the mean time, Muslim investors will have to bear with the available options of investments.
like i said, consciously investing in halal stock, non-interest bearing securities, Islamic mutual funds, insurance, education plans, Islamic loans are the way of investments for Muslim. if you think about it, there is a vast array of options for the ardent Islamic investor.
if you’re unsure of anything, one of the best people to consult is Dr Monzer Kahf. he’s an Islamic scholar on Islamic Finance, Banking and Economics. I know he has answered alot of my concerns!
ok then, the lunch has subsided with all that vigorous typing. salaam all, take care. hope this helps.
Allah knows best.
